Yale Daily News has given a 7 out of 10. The ancient album is called Nevermind, and it's by Nirvana. You may have heard of them because they're the band the Foo Fighters grew out of.
Anyway, this is definitely worth hearing because Nirvana has inspired everyone from Nickelback to Lana Del Rey, and Pitchfork declared the record to be an all-time classic. Now granted, they're no Radiohead, but for an ancient band, they're really not that bad.
[postscript: It's also possible that this review is one of the best dry, sarcastic jokes put to paper. But all of the guy's other by-lines are legit. Also the YDN is not known for dry, sarcastic humor. I think it's real... but if it's fake, the guy's a genius.]